Which Image is Real? Fall Colors

Below are 4 images.

Only one is real. I know this because I took it myself.

My photo is of some trees in their full peak fall glory on the campus of Tufts University in Boston.

The other images are AI-generated. I created them using Ideogram.ai.

Which one do you think is the real image? See the answer below!

The real image of the trees is:

Image #4

Some clues that give away the AI images:

🍂 1. Leaf Color and Transitions

#4 (REAL):

• The trees show natural, uneven transitions in color — some leaves are fully green, others are patchy blends of orange and red.
• The distribution is messy and imperfect, with random clusters of color that reflect how fall foliage actually changes.

AIArtificial Intelligence (AI) is basically when computers get smart—really smart. Imagine if your c... More:

• #1 and #2 have suspiciously “gradient-like” transitions, almost like someone airbrushed the trees from red to yellow to green in perfect order.
• #3’s colors bleed into each other too smoothly, with less of the irregular patchiness you’d expect in real autumn trees.

🌳 2. Tree and Canopy Shapes

#4:

• Each tree has a distinct shape and branching pattern — one’s lopsided, another is fuller, and the red tree is narrower. That natural asymmetry is typical of real growth.
• The canopies overlap just enough to look organic, with subtle gaps where sky shows through.

AI:

• #1 and #2 have unnaturally uniform shapes, almost too “perfectly trimmed.”
• #3’s trees lean toward symmetry, with smoother edges that feel painted rather than grown.

🌞 3. Lighting and Shadows

#4:

• The grass shadows are soft and irregular, consistent with sunlight filtering through large, uneven canopies.
• The light reflects differently on each tree depending on its color and density, adding natural variation.

AI:

• #1 and #2 show overly crisp or exaggerated shadows that don’t always line up with canopy density.
• #3’s shadowing is flat in some spots, lacking depth.

📸 4. Ground and Background Details

#4:

• The grass shows subtle imperfections — small patches, fallen leaves, and uneven texture across the slope.
• The horizon trees in the distance are varied and messy, with realistic overlaps instead of repeating shapes.

AI:

#3 has clean gradients of grass color but lacks the messy ground details you’d expect.

#1 and #2 have lawns that look too smooth, like artificial turf.

New England Fall Foliage

There’s arguably no better place to witness fall foliage than in New England. If you don’t live there (or even if you do!), check out this stunning road trip through the area during peak color season.

More From the Senior Tech Cafe ‘Real or AI?’ Challenge

You can check out our archive of ‘Real or AI?’